September 27, 2004
September 27th, 2004Damn it, I hate when people agree with me before I get a chance to really rant: Leonard Pitts Jr, in a syndicated article for the Knight Ridder Tribune (”Rules Are Different For Minorities” [article no longer available online]), bemoaned the fact that Moslem groups are expected to publicly condemn Islamic terror attacks, and black politicians are called upon to denounce the likes of Louis Farrakhan but, say, Billy Graham isn’t asked to condemn abortion clinic bombings by Christians. I’d read this sort of thing before and the fallacy has always annoyed me, so I e-mailed Mr. Pitts to point out that when (for example) somebody blows up a building claiming he’s doing so in the name of Islam, then if Moslem leaders don’t condemn it they appear to be, by their silence, accepting this claim. And “different rules” are not really applying here: Reverend Graham was not required to disavow Eric Rudolph’s fatal bombing of an Alabama abortion clinic, because Rudolph didn’t do it in the name of Christianity — but anti-abortion groups were asked to denounce his violent solution.
Mr. Pitt e-mailed me back before the day was out, agreeing with me.